Best Arrows: 18 Hunting Shafts Built on One Bow, Picked by the Numbers
If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission that helps support the work we do. Learn more.
The best hunting arrow is the one whose spine matches your bow, built to a finished weight you can hit with at your longest shot. Brand comes last. I ran all 18 hunting shafts in the site's shaft database through one 70 lb bow, and once each was matched for spine, the picks below fell out of the numbers: Black Eagle Deep Impact for elk-class weight on a micro-diameter shaft, Easton 5mm FMJ Max as the all-round deer arrow, and Victory RIP XV for the flattest flight.
The bigger finding: KE barely moved across the 17 builds, 85 to 87 ft·lb. Momentum moved 21%. And five pairs of shafts from different brands came out nearly identical, because their GPI and diameter are.
- 450 grmedian total arrow weight posted by 41 ArcheryTalk hunters, 2024 to 2026
- 1.7×spread in grains per square inch of frontal area across 14 shafts at 70 lb (modeled)
- 37%of 322 voters in ArcheryTalk's 2025 brand poll shoot Victory; Easton was second at 29%
I rebuilt this page after a 2025 ArcheryTalk thread titled "Best" hunting arrows of 2025, quotes and all. Its opening post argued that make and model don't really matter if the arrows are strong and the right spine. I wanted to know if the numbers agree. Mostly, they do.
Enter your bow. It picks the matching spine in each of the 18 shafts, builds every arrow with your head weight and ranks the ones that fit by what you care about most. Same spine model as the Arrow Shaft Finder, same flight model as every other tool here.
What Are the Best Hunting Arrows in 2026?
Each pick is a measured job, not a ranking of brands. All of them are built the same way: 70 lb, 29 in draw, 340 fps IBO, 28.5 in arrow, 125 gr broadhead on a 16 gr insert, three 6 gr vanes. The spine is whatever each line offers closest to that bow.
| Job | Pick | Arrow | Why the numbers chose it | Close alternative |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Elk-class weight, thin | Black Eagle Deep Impact 300 | 482 gr | Most grains per sq in of all 14 shafts with a published diameter: 9,968 | CX Maxima Triad 300 (479 gr, 9,673) |
| All-round deer | Easton 5mm FMJ Max 300 | 462 gr | Closest to the 450 gr forum median with high density; aluminum jacket over carbon | Gold Tip Kinetic Kaos 300 (464 gr) |
| Flattest flight | Victory RIP XV 300 | 370 gr | Lightest build: 322 fps, least drop when you misjudge distance | Gold Tip Airstrike 300 (410 gr) |
| Thin and mid-weight | Easton 4mm Axis Long Range 300 | 433 gr | Second-thinnest shaft (.241 in) at a middle weight | Gold Tip Pierce Platinum 300 (427 gr, its spec twin) |
| Most momentum | CX D-Stroyer PileDriver 300 | 533 gr | Heaviest build: 0.641 slug·ft/s, 21% above the lightest | Deep Impact 300 (0.608, on a far thinner shaft) |
| Standard diameter | Gold Tip Hunter Pro 300 | 433 gr | ±.001 in straightness on a .302 in shaft that takes standard inserts and nocks | Easton Sonic 6.0 300 (419 gr) |
Modeled builds; straightness and diameters are each maker's published figures. Every row, plus a 60 lb deer setup, is in the best arrows data (CSV).
How Do 17 Hunting Arrows Compare on the Same Bow?
This is the full run, heaviest first. Victory's RIP TKO is left out because Victory doesn't publish its GPI per spine, and I won't guess it. Victory doesn't list outside diameters per spine either, so its three shafts show n/a for density.
| Shaft | Spine | GPI | Outside dia. | Arrow | fps | Momentum | Grains per sq in | Low at 45 yd, 40 yd pin (in) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carbon Express D-Stroyer PileDriver | 300 | 12.8 | 0.314″ | 533 gr | 271 | 0.641 | 6,880 | 7.2 |
| Black Eagle Deep Impact | 300 | 11 | 0.248″ | 482 gr | 284 | 0.608 | 9,968 | 6.5 |
| Carbon Express Maxima Triad | 300 | 10.9 | 0.251″ | 479 gr | 285 | 0.606 | 9,673 | 6.5 |
| Easton FMJ 6mm | 320 | 10.6 | 0.287″ | 470 gr | 288 | 0.600 | 7,267 | 6.4 |
| Gold Tip Kinetic Kaos | 300 | 10.4 | 0.274″ | 464 gr | 289 | 0.597 | 7,876 | 6.3 |
| Easton 5mm FMJ Max | 300 | 10.3 | 0.264″ | 462 gr | 290 | 0.595 | 8,432 | 6.3 |
| Victory VForce 245 Elite V1 | 300 | 9.9 | n/a | 450 gr | 294 | 0.587 | n/a | 6.1 |
| Easton 4mm Axis Long Range | 300 | 9.3 | 0.241″ | 433 gr | 299 | 0.575 | 9,493 | 5.9 |
| Gold Tip Hunter Pro | 300 | 9.3 | 0.302″ | 433 gr | 299 | 0.575 | 6,046 | 5.9 |
| Gold Tip Pierce Platinum | 300 | 9.1 | 0.240″ | 427 gr | 301 | 0.571 | 9,447 | 5.8 |
| Easton Sonic 6.0 | 300 | 8.8 | 0.286″ | 419 gr | 304 | 0.565 | 6,519 | 5.7 |
| Victory VAP | 300 | 8.7 | n/a | 416 gr | 305 | 0.563 | n/a | 5.7 |
| Black Eagle Rampage | 300 | 8.7 | 0.264″ | 416 gr | 305 | 0.563 | 7,599 | 5.7 |
| Gold Tip Airstrike | 300 | 8.5 | 0.262″ | 410 gr | 307 | 0.558 | 7,610 | 5.6 |
| Black Eagle Carnivore V2 | 300 | 8.5 | 0.296″ | 410 gr | 307 | 0.558 | 5,962 | 5.6 |
| Carbon Express Maxima Sable RZ 350 is its stiffest | 350 | 8.4 | 0.296″ | 407 gr | 308 | 0.556 | 5,920 | 5.6 |
| Victory RIP XV Elite V1 | 300 | 7.1 | n/a | 370 gr | 322 | 0.529 | n/a | 5.1 |
Built with my FOC optimizer engine, spine-matched with the same model as the carbon spine calculator. FOC runs 11.6 to 16.7% because every shaft carries the same 141 gr up front. GPI and diameter come from each maker's spec page, linked on the name.
Do Thinner Arrows Really Penetrate Better?
Thinner shafts put the same weight behind less frontal area, and that ratio is easy to compute from published specs. I call it grains per square inch: finished arrow weight divided by the shaft's cross-section. It's the archery version of sectional density, and it's the one number on this page where shafts of the same weight really differ.
Deep Impact and PileDriver show it best. The PileDriver is 51 gr heavier, but its .314 in shaft has 60% more frontal area than the Deep Impact's .248, so the Deep Impact carries 45% more grains per square inch. Less area also means less for a crosswind to push on.
What I can't give you from specs is a measured penetration difference. My KE and momentum calculator scores all 17 builds within a few points of each other, because its model runs on momentum, not on diameter. The thin-shaft benefit is physics you can count on directionally; how many inches it adds in an animal I don't have data for.
How Heavy Should a Hunting Arrow Be?
Most hunters who post their setup land between 430 and 480 gr. I went through six ArcheryTalk setup and arrow threads from 2024 to 2026 and pulled every total arrow weight a member posted for his own hunting arrow: 41 members, median 450 gr.
Weight hurts you in one place: a misjudged distance. With a 40 yd pin on an animal that's really at 45, the lightest build in the table lands 5.1 in low and the heaviest 7.2 in low. That's a 2.1 in difference for 21% more momentum.
So go heavier if you hunt elk or bigger and keep shots inside 40, and lighter if your shots run long and you can't always range them. Run your own setup through the KE and momentum calculator to see where the game thresholds fall.
Does Arrow Brand Matter?
Less than the spec sheet does. At the 70 lb reference, five pairs of shafts from different makers came out within 9 gr and .010 in of each other, because their GPI and diameter nearly match:
| Shaft | Its twin | GPI | Outside dia. | Arrow |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Easton 4mm Axis Long Range 300 | Gold Tip Pierce Platinum 300 | 9.3 / 9.1 | .241 / .240 | 433 / 427 gr |
| Black Eagle Deep Impact 300 | CX Maxima Triad 300 | 11.0 / 10.9 | .248 / .251 | 482 / 479 gr |
| Easton 5mm FMJ Max 300 | Gold Tip Kinetic Kaos 300 | 10.3 / 10.4 | .264 / .274 | 462 / 464 gr |
| Gold Tip Airstrike 300 | Black Eagle Rampage 300 | 8.5 / 8.7 | .262 / .264 | 410 / 416 gr |
| Black Eagle Carnivore V2 300 | Easton Sonic 6.0 300 | 8.5 / 8.8 | .296 / .286 | 410 / 419 gr |
What the spec sheet doesn't show is how a shaft holds up. The FMJ family's aluminum jacket is the one durability difference I have forum data on, tallied in Axis vs FMJ durability.
Which Arrow Brands Do Hunters Actually Shoot?
ArcheryTalk's 2025 arrow popularity poll closed with 322 voters. In the six setup threads I read, 203 members posted and 133 named at least one shaft. The most-named lines, counted once per member: Gold Tip in any model 41, Victory RIP XV or TKO 34, Easton Axis 29, Easton Sonic or 5.0 25, Black Eagle in any model 14, Easton FMJ 11.
Popularity tells you what's easy to find at a shop and what other hunters can help you tune. It doesn't tell you which shaft fits your bow; the Shortlist above does.
What If You Don't Shoot a Compound?
The 18-shaft list is compound hunting shafts. For other bows, the shaft type matters more than the model:
| Bow | Start with | Size it with |
|---|---|---|
| Beginner or youth recurve | Aluminum, such as Easton's XX75 line | XX75 aluminum spine chart |
| Olympic-style recurve | Thin alloy-carbon for outdoor, fat shafts indoors | recurve spine calculator |
| Longbow or traditional recurve | Wood, or carbon built heavy | wood spine calculator |
| Not sure yet | Match material to bow and use first | Arrow Type Finder |
Decide the finished weight first, from your game and your longest shot. Then pick the thinnest shaft that gets there in the spine your bow needs, and buy the one your shop can supply and help you tune. If two shafts tie on paper, they'll tie in the field more often than not.
For most whitetail setups that means something near 450 gr; the FMJ Max is my pick there. For elk, go heavier on a thin shaft like the Deep Impact. Then paper-tune or bareshaft-tune before you trust any of it.
Shoot a shaft that isn't in the 18, or have a published spec I've got wrong? Tell me through the contact page and I'll add or fix it.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best hunting arrows?
The ones spine-matched to your bow at a finished weight you can hit with. On a 70 lb reference bow, the numbers picked Black Eagle Deep Impact for elk-class weight on a thin shaft, Easton 5mm FMJ Max as an all-round deer arrow near 450 gr, and Victory RIP XV for the flattest flight.
How heavy should a hunting arrow be?
Most hunters who post their setups shoot 430 to 480 gr; the median of 41 ArcheryTalk members was 450 gr. Go heavier for elk and short shots, lighter for long shots you can't always range. At 70 lb, a 533 gr arrow carried 21% more momentum than a 370 gr one in my model.
Are thinner arrows better for hunting?
At the same weight, yes in principle: a thinner shaft puts more grains behind each square inch of frontal area and gives wind less to push on. Across 14 shafts at 70 lb that figure ranged from about 5,900 to 10,000 grains per square inch. I don't have measured penetration data for the difference.
Does arrow brand matter?
Less than spine, weight and diameter. Five pairs of shafts from different brands built within 9 gr and .010 in of each other at 70 lb, because their published GPI and diameter nearly match. Pick the one your shop stocks and can help you tune.
What arrow brand is most popular?
In ArcheryTalk's 2025 poll of 322 voters, Victory led with 37%, then Beman and Easton with 29%, Gold Tip and Bass Pro with 11% and Black Eagle with 9%.
Does heavier arrow weight change kinetic energy?
Barely, from the same bow. Across 17 builds from 370 to 533 gr at 70 lb, my model gave 85 to 87 ft-lb. Momentum rose 21% from the lightest to the heaviest, which is why heavy-arrow hunters talk about momentum.
What spine arrow do I need for a 70 lb bow?
Usually a 300 spine at a 28 to 29 in arrow with a 100 to 125 gr head, which is what nearly every shaft here matched to on the reference bow. Arrow length, point weight and cam change it, so run your numbers in the Arrow Shortlist or the carbon spine calculator.
Hey, what's up? Burak here. Archery addict, board game geek, Daft Punk fan.